Dear Queriers, Part 2

September 27, 2009 in Agent | 3 comments

I am back from New York and catching up on queries slowly but surely. I respond to absolutely everyone who queries me, so if you have in the last two weeks, you’ll be hearing back soon.

Which brings me to another point. Several queries have come in recently that use this technique:

Dear Ms. Kole,

You are an aspiring garbagegirl in Brooklyn who is allergic to flies. And your mom says you have to go to beauty college when you get out of high school. Your world turns upside down one day when a faerie vampire crashes through your bedroom window…

This is a <sarcasm>fun</sarcasm> new spin on my absolute pet peeve: the rhetorical question query. And the use of second person in general, when it’s not earned or warranted. I don’t understand this technique… and there are several examples of it in my slush. Did some blog somewhere tell well-meaning writers that this was the new no-fail query fad?

I understand it’s meant to be arresting and pulse-pounding, it’s meant to grab me and never let me go and all that junk, but here’s the reason it bugs me: I want to read about you and your work. LEAVE ME OUT OF IT!

The example up there is one I wrote. But it’s not too far off from what I’ve been seeing. And honestly? Instead of thinking “Wow, that sounds cool,” I immediately think: “I am NOT a garbagegirl, my mom does NOT want me to go to beauty college and there’s no way in heck that a faerie vampire is crashing through MY window without picking up the repair bill!”

And you don’t want me to be thinking about ME when I’m reading YOUR query, right? Didn’t think so.

Tags:

  1. ChristaCarol’s avatar

    ChristaCarol on October 4, 2009 at 7:33 pm

    You’re probably not too far off in your guessing (if you’re getting in a handful that are like this) that someone somewhere on a blog out there said this was a great idea. Who knows! But now the news can be spread to counter it. Great blog, by the way, just found it.

  2. Beth Browne’s avatar

    Beth Browne on October 17, 2009 at 6:23 pm

    Hi Mary,

    It certainly sounds like a very frustrating trend for you to deal with. But what if the *book* is written in second person? I thought the query was supposed to give you a feel for the writing in the book? Obviously, this is not your thing, but might it be someone else’s? (I know, hard to imagine, right?) And hey, on the up side, you need read no further (and waste your time) on this particular book or author.

    Btw, I am really enjoying your site. Thanks!

  3. Mary’s avatar

    Mary on October 17, 2009 at 6:28 pm

    Beth — Very good point. Of course, if the book is written in second person and that’s something interesting that I want to look into, I’ll keep reading. But this is a 2nd person lead to a query for a book that is written in first or third person. I have yet to see a book written in 2nd person, with this query lead or without.

    Once I see some premise — if I even suspect that it must be The Book — I will overcome any number of pet peeves and personal annoyances. I should probably make this clear in a post at some point or another.